Huldra Forsvant (Theodor Kittelsen)

Huldra Forsvant (Theodor Kittelsen)
Huldra Forsvant (Theodor Kittelsen)

Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Book Review Wednesday by Kim

Everything Is Illuminated
By Jonathan Safran Foer (2002)

Review by Kim

Usually when I start a book and can’t quite keep the characters or situations straight it doesn’t worry me too much and I keep on until it all becomes clear, or, occasionally, I flip back when I realized I’ve mistakenly misplaced a major character.

It’s generally a good method because usually everything is eventually illuminated. Except in the only book that actually promises illumination in the title.

I made it to the end but still don’t quite understand the second chapter, or who’s who, or, more to the point, who’s not who, or how who connects to who, much less what.

It’s a bit like Tom Stoppard’s absurdist theatre squashed 2-D. You know it’s brilliant (goodness knows it’s won enough awards), but you’re at a loss to identify much more than a generous handful of themes. Writing, sex, the Holocaust, Ukraine, sex, Jews, character, history, ancestry, light, sex and possibly dead arms spring to mind, but how exactly they all relate is still a bit unclear.

Let’s just say I feel out of the loop, but oddly illuminated.

Thanks Kim. Sounds like one I may need to avoid for fear of feeling even dumber.

2 comments:

Stuart Heath said...

Wow! Looks like Kim and I share some reading interests. Maybe I should be submitting book reviews, rather than just posting them in comments :P

I love this book, and his second. Reflections here:
http://leslumieres-au.blogspot.com/2007/07/two-first-novels.html
http://leslumieres-au.blogspot.com/2007/08/extremely-loud-and-incredibly-close.html

KIM said...

interesting, stuart! i checked out your review and it makes so much more sense than mine does! i read it and went, oh, yes, yes, that's right. that's exactly the same book i read. except he explained it so much more succinctly!

i agree that alex's narration is the highlight by far. like you said possibly of the other book's narrator, it's missing something when he's absent. and sammy davis, jr., jr. might have been my very favorite character!

not sure about the ending. i won't say too much here, but i didn't love it. not that i had a better idea, but ... it didn't blow me away in the same way.

though like i said, the whole thing did make me feel highly sophisticated for the reading!